Skip to main content

Table 2 Toxicity classification calculations for each flavouring compound using the maximum concentrations reported by Vardavas et al.

From: Toxicity classification of e-cigarette flavouring compounds based on European Union regulation: analysis of findings from a recent study

Substance

Hazard category

Reported max concentration

(% w/w)*

Calculated ATEmix

ATEmix limit or min concentration for toxicity classification

% difference**

Menthol

Η315 Category 2

0.4991

 

10

− 95.0%

Η319 Category 2

0.4991

 

10

− 95.0%

Ethyl maltol

Η302 Category 4

7.096

7046

≤ 2000

− 71.6%

Linalool

Η315 Category 2

0.263

 

10

− 97.4%

Η317 Category 1

0.263

 

1

− 73.7%

Η319 Category 2

0.263

 

10

− 97.4%

Methyl cyclopentenolone

Η302 Category 4

2.5067

19,946

≤ 2000

− 90.0%

Η319 Category 2

2.5067

 

10

− 74.9%

Η334 Category 1

2.5067

 

1

150.7%

Η335 Category 3

2.5067

 

20

− 87.5%

β-Damascone

Η317 Category 1

0.0742

 

1

− 92.6%

Η411 Category 2

0.0742

 

25

− 99.7%

Ethyl vanillin

Η302 Category 4

0.9135

54,734

≤ 2000

− 96.3%

Η315 Category 2

0.9135

 

10

− 90.9%

Η319 Category 2

0.9135

 

10

− 90.9%

Η335 Category 3

0.9135

 

20

− 95.4%

Η412 Category 3

0.9135

 

25

− 96.3%

β-Ionone

Η400 Category 1

0.0076

 

25

> − 99.9%

Η411 Category 2

0.0076

 

25

> − 99.9%

Acetyl pyrazine

Η315 Category 2

0.1067

 

10

− 98.9%

Η319 Category 2

0.1067

 

10

− 98.9%

Η335 Category 3

0.1067

 

20

− 99.5%

α-Ionone

Η334 Category 1

0.012

 

1

− 98.8%

Η412 Category 3

0.012

 

25

> − 99.9%

2,5 Dimethylpyrazine

Η302 Category 4

0.0197

2,538,071

≤ 2000

− 99.9%

α-Damascone

Η302 Category 4

0.0078

6,410,256

≤ 2000

> − 99.9%

Η317 Category 1

0.0078

 

1

− 99.2%

Η411 Category 2

0.0078

 

25

> − 99.9%

3,4 Dimethoxy-benzaldehyde

Η302 Category 4

0.0359

1,392,757

≤ 2000

− 99.9%

Limonene

Η304 Category 1

0.0001

 

10

> − 99.9%

Η315 Category 2

0.0001

 

10

> − 99.9%

Η317 Category 1

0.0001

 

1

> − 99.9%

Η400 Category 1

0.0001

 

25

> − 99.9%

Η410 Category 1

0.0001

 

25

> − 99.9%

  1. *Maximum concentrations reported by Vardavas et al
  2. **Percent difference between the maximum concentration reported by Vardavas et al. and the concentration needed to be classified as toxic
  3. Italics represents the compound and hazard exceeding the limits for toxicity classification