Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of identified themes

From: Contextual factors affecting the implementation of drug checking for harm reduction: a scoping literature review from a North American perspective

Theme

Key findings

Drug checking technologies

 Patron perspectives

Wait time, cost, and sample destruction were identified as barriers to service utilization

Highly accurate, quantitative results are preferred by patrons

 Fentanyl test strips

Fentanyl test strips are seen as highly accepted and easy to use

A wide variety of locations were suggested as distribution sites

 Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR)

Use of FTIR was commonly reported in the literature, with variable results

Benefits include broad range of substances detected, lower cost, and improved portability compared to MS technologies

Limitations include a high detection limit, and poorer sensitivity and specificity compared to laboratory-based technologies

 Mass spectrometry (MS)

New MS technologies have been employed for harm reduction and may offer improved technological specifications (detection limits, accuracy, etc.) compared to FTIR

Limitations include high cost, expertise needed for operation, and physical site requirements

Venue

 Patron perspectives

Patrons emphasized the need for assessable services with convenient locations and hours of operation

Mobile services may help facilitate plausible deniability, outreach to rural patrons, and adaptive response to local drug trends by allowing services to be provided in high-need or high-risk areas

 Integration of services

Integration of drug checking with other services was reported with mixed results

Integration may capitalize on trust and comfortability if patrons already use services at an existing site, and may help bridge patrons to other harm reduction services

Integration of services may be a barrier to some patrons who fear stigma associated with a site or its services

 Other

Peers or people with lived experience were seen as important for developing trust in patrons

Communication of results should be informative on the substances identified and appeal to a wide range of patrons

Legality

Legality was the most commonly reported barrier to service utilization

Criminalization was a major concern for both patrons and staff members

Privacy

Patrons are concerned with being identified physically, and through inappropriate use of their information